Totally agree - I see this paper as a snapshot in time, not as a final assessment. That's why it's so important to continuously iterate, measure its value, and adopt newer tools/models.
I find AI code reviews quite powerful for catching repetitive mistakes and keeping code style consistent, but they often miss the ‘why’ behind the code. Tools are getting better, but context, design trade-offs, and mentoring still need human eyes. In my view, AI should be seen as a helpful assistant, not a replacement. It can handle the boring parts, so humans can focus on what really matters: thoughtful design and team learning. Curious to see how others balance AI suggestions with their own judgment.
Definitely! I think the data is consistently showing that it's an augment for engineering processes, but not yet a full replacement. It will be interesting to see how that evolves as it builds more context and the models mature.
Heavy correlation here with the quality of the models and a rapidly evolving space.
I’d be very curious to see how this trends with reasoning models and reviews that can more effectively gather relevant codebase context
Totally agree - I see this paper as a snapshot in time, not as a final assessment. That's why it's so important to continuously iterate, measure its value, and adopt newer tools/models.
I find AI code reviews quite powerful for catching repetitive mistakes and keeping code style consistent, but they often miss the ‘why’ behind the code. Tools are getting better, but context, design trade-offs, and mentoring still need human eyes. In my view, AI should be seen as a helpful assistant, not a replacement. It can handle the boring parts, so humans can focus on what really matters: thoughtful design and team learning. Curious to see how others balance AI suggestions with their own judgment.
Definitely! I think the data is consistently showing that it's an augment for engineering processes, but not yet a full replacement. It will be interesting to see how that evolves as it builds more context and the models mature.